Name: Barefoot Contessa Tea Sandwiches
Prep time: 30 min
Cook time: 30 min
Total time: 1 h
Ingredients: ½ large English cucumber; 4 oz cream cheese, softened; Zest of ½ lemon; Pinch of salt; 1 tbsp fresh dill, chopped; 6 slices soft white or potato bread; 4 oz smoked salmon; ½ cucumber, thinly sliced; 2 oz cream cheese (same mixture as above); Dill for garnish; 6 slices pumpernickel bread; 4 hard-boiled eggs; 2 tbsp unsalted butter, softened; 1 tbsp mayonnaise; Pinch of paprika; 6 slices white bread; Optional: chopped watercress; 3 boneless chicken breasts; ¼ tsp dried thyme; 3 tbsp olive oil; 2 oz fresh cranberries, halved and crushed; 1 tbsp mayonnaise; 2 tsp Dijon mustard; Watercress or arugula; 6 slices potato bread

Jump to Recipe Jump to Video Print Recipe

I used to think tea sandwiches were all style, no substance. Pretty on a platter, forgettable in flavor.

Then I hosted a small garden brunch and decided to make them the Ina way—elegant, balanced, and deceptively simple.

Here’s how I turned four classic fillings into something worth making again (and again).

Why This Works So Well

The secret is intention. Ina doesn’t just pile fillings onto bread and call it done—each sandwich has a clear, balanced flavor profile. The cucumber-dill is cool and herby, the salmon is rich but bright, the egg is velvety and savory, and the cranberry chicken is sweet, tangy, and layered.

Every bite has contrast—soft against crisp, tangy against mellow—and that’s what makes them memorable.

My Ingredient Notes

Cucumber (English, preferably) – Thinly sliced, it adds crunch and freshness. I once used a standard waxy cucumber and regretted it—the seeds made the sandwich soggy.

Cream cheese (full-fat, room temp) – The base for both the cucumber and salmon spreads. I use Philadelphia; the texture holds better than store-brand.

Lemon zest – Not juice—zest. It perfumes the spread without watering it down.

Dill (fresh, not dried) – Ina never shortcuts herbs. The dill lifts the salmon and cucumber versions without overpowering them.

Pumpernickel bread – For the salmon. Its boldness matches the smoky fish. Don’t substitute white bread—it just doesn’t stand up.

Eggs (hard-boiled, still warm) – Warm eggs mash more smoothly. I peel them while they’re slightly hot and mix while warm for the creamiest texture.

Cranberries (fresh or frozen, halved and crushed) – I’ve tried dried cranberries here. Too chewy. Go fresh and give them a rough crush to release their tartness.

Dijon mustard – This is the backbone of the chicken salad—don’t skip or swap it.

Swaps That Actually Worked

Chicken – Once swapped with leftover roast turkey. Slightly drier, but still lovely.
Pumpernickel – Tried a dense rye once; it worked, but needed more salt in the spread.
Dairy-Free Cream Cheese – Used Kite Hill for a vegan guest. It held up fine, but I added a pinch of salt and lemon juice to perk it up.

Fixes That Mattered

What Went Wrong	Why It Happens	How to Fix It
Soggy bread	Warm fillings or wet cucumbers	Pat cucumbers dry and cool all fillings before assembling
Salmon slid around	Too much spread or too thick cucumber slices	Keep spread thin, cucumbers very thin, and press gently before cutting
Egg filling too dry	Overcooked eggs, not enough mayo	Use freshly boiled eggs, mash while warm, and adjust mayo slowly

How to Make Ina Garten’s Tea Sandwiches

1. Cranberry Chicken Sandwiches

Roast seasoned chicken breasts at 350°F for 30 minutes. Cool, then chop.
Roughly crush halved cranberries in a bowl.
Mix mayonnaise and Dijon mustard in a separate bowl.
Combine chicken, cranberries, and mayo mixture.
Spread on buttered white bread. Add a few watercress leaves.
Trim crusts and cut into neat squares.

2. Cucumber Dill Sandwiches

Stir softened cream cheese with chopped dill, lemon zest, and a pinch of salt.
Spread on soft potato bread.
Layer paper-thin cucumber slices (I use a mandoline).
Trim crusts, cut into fingers or squares.

3. Smoked Salmon Sandwiches

Spread the same dill-cream cheese mix on pumpernickel.
Add thin cucumbers, then layers of smoked salmon.
Use a round cutter or leave square. Garnish with a piped dot of cream cheese and a dill sprig.

4. Egg Salad Sandwiches

Mash warm, hard-boiled eggs with butter, mayo, paprika, and salt.
Spread on buttered white or potato bread.
Optional: a few watercress leaves.
Trim, cut, and serve.

Tiny Habits, Better Results

Use a microplane for the lemon zest—it melts into the spread, no grittiness.
Chill the sandwiches under a damp paper towel before serving. Keeps them fresh and just the right texture.
When in doubt, press the sandwiches gently before cutting—less mess.

Leftover Notes

Fridge: Wrap tightly in plastic and keep in an airtight container. Best within 24 hours, but up to 2 days.
Freezer: Don’t freeze the cucumber or egg ones—they don’t thaw well. The cranberry chicken freezes decently if you freeze the filling separately.
Reheat: Skip the microwave. These are meant to be served cold or at room temp. That’s part of their charm.

Before You Make It…

Q: Can I prep these the day before?
A: Yes, but don’t assemble them more than 6 hours ahead. You can prep all the fillings the night before and store each in its own container.

Q: What’s the best knife for trimming tea sandwiches?
A: A serrated bread knife works best—use a gentle sawing motion to avoid squishing the fillings.

Q: Can I make these gluten-free?
A: Yes. Canyon Bakehouse makes a great soft GF white bread that trims well and holds together.

Try More Recipes:

Barefoot Contessa Tea Sandwiches

Author: Hamdi Saidani Cooking Method:Roasting Cuisine:American Courses:Appetizers Recipe Keys: T Tea Sandwiches

Difficulty:BeginnerPrep time: 30 minutesCook time: 30 minutesRest time: minutesTotal time:1 hour Servings:12 servingsCalories:82 kcal Best Season:Suitable throughout the year

Description

Four classic tea sandwiches—cucumber, salmon, egg, and cranberry chicken—perfectly balanced and elegant enough for any gathering.

Ingredients

Cucumber Dill Sandwich

½ large English cucumber
4 oz cream cheese, softened
Zest of ½ lemon
Pinch of salt
1 tbsp fresh dill, chopped
6 slices soft white or potato bread

Salmon Sandwich

4 oz smoked salmon
½ cucumber, thinly sliced
2 oz cream cheese (same mixture as above)
Dill for garnish
6 slices pumpernickel bread

Egg Salad Sandwich

4 hard-boiled eggs
2 tbsp unsalted butter, softened
1 tbsp mayonnaise
Pinch of paprika
6 slices white bread
Optional: chopped watercress

Cranberry Chicken Sandwich

3 boneless chicken breasts
¼ tsp dried thyme
3 tbsp olive oil
2 oz fresh cranberries, halved and crushed
1 tbsp mayonnaise
2 tsp Dijon mustard
Watercress or arugula
6 slices potato bread

Instructions

Cranberry Chicken Sandwiches

Preheat oven to 350°F. Rub chicken with olive oil, thyme, and salt. Roast for 30 minutes. Cool and dice into small chunks.
Crush cranberries roughly in a bowl.
Mix mayonnaise and Dijon in a separate bowl.
Combine chicken, cranberries, and mayo mixture.
Spread butter on bread (optional), add chicken filling, and top with greens.
Trim crusts, cut into squares or fingers.

Cucumber Dill Sandwiches

Mix cream cheese, lemon zest, dill, and salt until smooth.
Spread mixture onto white bread.
Put the cream cheese mixture on the white Top with paper-thin cucumber slices.
and then add the cucumber pieces.
Trim crusts, slice into fingers or squares.

Smoked Salmon Sandwiches

Spread dill cream cheese mixture on pumpernickel slices.
Layer cucumber, then smoked salmon.
Optional: Cut into circles using a round cutter.
Garnish with a piped dollop of cream cheese and dill sprig.

Egg Salad Sandwiches

Mash warm hard-boiled eggs with butter, mayonnaise, and paprika.
Fold in chopped watercress if using.
Spread on white bread slices.
Trim crusts, slice neatly.

Keywords:Barefoot Contessa Tea Sandwiches